All Expanded Criteria Donor Kidneys are Equal But are Some More Equal Than Others? A Population-Cohort Analysis of UK Transplant Registry Data
Patel, Kamlesh Brotherton, Anna Chaudhry, Daoud Evison, Felicity Nieto, Thomas Dabare, Dilan Sharif, Adnan
Patel, Kamlesh
Brotherton, Anna
Chaudhry, Daoud
Evison, Felicity
Nieto, Thomas
Dabare, Dilan
Sharif, Adnan
Abstract
Survival outcomes for kidney transplant candidates based on expanded criteria donor (ECD) kidney type is unknown. A retrospective cohort study was undertaken of prospectively collected registry data of all waitlisted kidney failure patients receiving dialysis in the United Kingdom. All patients listed for their first kidney-alone transplant between 2000-2019 were included. Treatment types included; living donor; standard criteria donor (SCD); ECD60 (deceased donor aged ≥60 years); ECD50-59 (deceased donor aged 50-59 years with two from the following three; hypertension; raised creatinine and/or death from stroke) or remains on dialysis. The primary outcome was all-cause mortality, with time-to-death from listing analyzed using time-dependent non-proportional Cox regression models. The study cohort comprised 47,917 waitlisted kidney failure patients, of whom 34,558 (72.1%) received kidney transplantation. ECD kidneys (n = 7,356) were stratified as ECD60 (n = 7,009) or ECD50-59 (n = 347). Compared to SCD, both ECD60 (Hazard Ratio 1.126, 95% CI 1.093-1.161) and ECD50-59 (Hazard Ratio 1.228, 95% CI 1.113-1.356) kidney recipients have higher all-cause mortality. However, compared to dialysis, both ECD60 (Hazard Ratio 0.194, 95% CI 0.187-0.201) and ECD50-59 (Hazard Ratio 0.218, 95% CI 0.197-0.241) kidney recipients have lower all-cause mortality. ECD kidneys, regardless of definition, provide equivalent and superior survival benefits in comparison to remaining waitlisted.
Citations
Altmetric:
Date
2023-09-04
Type
Article
Subject
Urology
Collections
Citation
Patel K, Brotherton A, Chaudhry D, Evison F, Nieto T, Dabare D, Sharif A. All Expanded Criteria Donor Kidneys are Equal But are Some More Equal Than Others? A Population-Cohort Analysis of UK Transplant Registry Data. Transpl Int. 2023 Sep 4;36:11421. doi: 10.3389/ti.2023.11421. PMID: 37727380; PMCID: PMC10505656.
Journal / Source Title
Transplant International
DOI
10.3389/ti.2023.11421
PMID
37727380
Publisher
Frontiers Media
Publisher’s URL
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/10.1111/(ISSN)1432-2277