Choice of faecal immunochemical test matters: comparison of OC-Sensor and HM-JACKarc, in the assessment of patients at high risk of colorectal cancer
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Currently, NICE recommends the use of faecal immunochemical test (FIT) at faecal haemoglobin concentrations (f-Hb) of 10 mug Hb/g faeces to stratify for colorectal cancer (CRC) risk in symptomatic populations. This f-Hb cut-off is advised across all analysers, despite the fact that a direct comparison of analyser performance, in a clinical setting, has not been performed., METHODS: Two specimen collection devices (OC-Sensor, OC-S; HM-JACKarc, HM-J) were sent to 914 consecutive individuals referred for follow up due to their increased risk of CRC. Agreement of f-Hb around cut-offs of 4, 10 and 150 microg Hb/g faeces and CRC detection rates were assessed. Two OC-S devices were sent to a further 114 individuals, for within test comparisons., RESULTS: A total of 732 (80.1%) individuals correctly completed and returned two different FIT devices, with 38 (5.2%) CRCs detected. Median f-Hb for individuals diagnosed with and without CRC were 258.5 and 1.8 microg Hb/g faeces for OC-S and 318.1 and 1.0 microg Hb/g faeces for HM-J respectively. Correlation of f-Hb results between OC-S/HM-J over the full range was rho=0.74, p<0.001. Using a f-Hb of 4 microg Hb/g faeces for both tests found an agreement of 88.1%, at 10 microg Hb/g faeces 91.7% and at 150 microg Hb/g faeces 96.3%. A total of 114 individuals completed and returned two OC-S devices; correlation across the full range was rho=0.98, p<0.001., CONCLUSIONS: We found large variations in f-Hb when different FIT devices were used, but a smaller variation when the same FIT device was used. Our data suggest that analyser-specific f-Hb cut-offs are applied with regard to clinical decision making, especially at lower f-Hb. Copyright © 2020 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston.
Citations
Altmetric:
Date
2021
Type
Article
Subject
Colorectal neoplasms, Faecal immunochemical testing
Collections
Citation
Chapman, C.J., Banerjea, A., Humes, D.J., Allen, J., Oliver, S., Ford, A., Hardy, K., Djedovic, N., Logan, R.F. and Morling, J.R. (2021) 'Choice of faecal immunochemical test matters: comparison of OC-Sensor and HM-JACKarc, in the assessment of patients at high risk of colorectal cancer', Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine, 59(4), pp. 721-728. doi: 10.1515/cclm-2020-1170.
Journal / Source Title
DOI
PMID
Publisher
De Gruyter